Transformation & Change

Estimating the Cost of a Reorganisation Realistically

Marin Niehues5 December 202410 min read

Team with laptops at a long table

The cost of a reorganisation arises in four layers, and the largest never appears on an invoice: the loss of productivity during the transition period. Budgeting only for fees and relocations captures a fraction of the total burden. This article works through the cost model with an example and sets out how severance pay and provisions fit in. This article provides an overview and does not constitute legal advice.

What costs does a reorganisation involve?

A reorganisation involves project costs, implementation costs, transition costs and a contingency for corrections. Executive teams usually budget a reorganisation as a project with a schedule and a total. That view captures the spending that appears on invoices. It misses the costs in day-to-day operations that arise because staff and managers do their work more slowly during the change. A four-layer cost model makes both sides visible.

Layers 1 and 2 can be derived bottom-up from work packages. Layers 3 and 4 rest on assumptions that are documented and reviewed regularly. Showing the two groups separately tells the executive team which part of the budget is evidenced and which part is a reasoned estimate. The overall framework of structure and delivery capability is described in the article characteristics and metrics of a high-performing organization.

Project and implementation costs are the visible part

For the first two layers, every work package gets an owner and an effort in person-days with a day rate, internal and external alike. Internal time belongs in the calculation. During a reorganisation, managers spend many days in alignment meetings and workshops, and those days are missing from daily business. A budget that contains only external invoices underestimates the effort from the first week.

External support is billed in the market by day rate. According to the fee study of the German management consultants' association BDU, day rates range roughly from 1,000 to 2,500 euros per consultant day, reflecting seniority and specialization.

Implementation includes costs that rarely appear in the project plan. New roles have to be filled, internally with onboarding time, externally with search time and vacancies. Reporting lines and cost centers must be adjusted in the systems, as must access rights. The article on planning a reorganisation provides the basis for process and duration. Duration is the most important cost driver, because every week of delay raises project costs and transition costs at the same time.

How much severance pay does a restructuring involve?

The planning anchor for severance in Germany is half a month's earnings per year of service, as provided for by Section 1a of the Protection Against Dismissal Act (KSchG) for dismissals on operational grounds. This value applies when the employer offers the payment in the notice of dismissal and the employee forgoes legal action. Termination agreements and social plans adopt the formula of length of service and gross monthly earnings, often with a factor above 0.5. The budget should therefore be calculated with two factors: 0.5 for the expected scenario and a higher factor for the stressed one.

Whether a social plan arises follows from the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). For an operational change in a company with more than 20 employees entitled to vote, employer and works council negotiate a reconciliation of interests and a social plan, and the social plan can be enforced through the conciliation board. Where the operational change consists solely of headcount reduction, enforceability applies only above certain thresholds under Section 112a BetrVG. The timing side is covered in the article Co-determination in reorganisations. The assessment of the individual case belongs with employment law specialists.

The transition is the largest hidden item

During the transition, old and new structures apply side by side. Responsibilities are partly settled and partly open, and decisions wait for roles that have not yet been filled. Interfaces that used to rely on personal relationships stop working. The result is a loss of productivity whose depth follows the number of roles affected and whose duration follows the clarity of the new decision paths.

The calculation follows a simple logic: employees affected times onboarding period times assumed loss of output during that time. The loss of output is an assumption and is kept as such in the assumptions register, with an owner and a review date.

For the executive team, this effect becomes visible in delivery. Deadlines slip, lead times grow, customers wait longer for answers. Before implementation begins, a baseline measurement of on-time delivery and lead time in the affected units is therefore essential. Without that baseline, neither the loss can be quantified later nor the recovery demonstrated.

Loss of knowledge is a separate item. When roles disappear or change hands, tacit knowledge about customers and systems drops out of the workflows. Planned handovers and named key people reduce this item.

How large should the contingency be?

The contingency should amount to ten to 25 percent of layers 1 to 3 and is derived from the difference between an expected and a stressed scenario. The lower end applies when the company has experience from an earlier reorganisation or a first implementation stage and less than a quarter of the workforce is affected. The upper end applies to a first reorganisation of this size. The same holds when severance accounts for more than half of layer 2. With every stage released, uncertainty falls and the contingency is reset.

How are restructuring costs accounted for?

Restructuring costs are recognized as a provision to the extent that an obligation to third parties exists, for example from severance pay or a social plan. Under the German Commercial Code (HGB), provisions must be made for uncertain liabilities (Section 249 HGB). Pure costs of the change, such as training or relocations, are not a liability and are expensed as incurred. Under IFRS, IAS 37 governs restructuring provisions: they require a detailed formal plan and a valid expectation raised in those affected, for example by an announcement or the start of implementation. Only direct expenditure arising from the restructuring may be included, and retraining or relocating continuing staff is expressly excluded. The treatment in a specific set of accounts is a matter for auditors and tax advisers.

For planning, one rule follows: the timing of the announcement helps determine in which financial year the costs hit the result. The finance function therefore belongs in the project team from the diagnosis onwards.

Four rules make the estimate robust

The first rule calls for two scenarios: an expected one and a stressed one in which duration is longer and the loss of output higher. The difference between them determines the contingency in layer 4.

The second rule keeps an assumptions register. Every assumption gets an owner and a review date. If an assumption is disproved, the correction goes straight into the estimate.

The third rule releases the budget in stages. After the analysis comes a first release for design, then a second for implementation in one unit, then the roll-out. Each stage provides experience for the next.

The fourth rule sets costs against benefits. A reorganisation is an investment, and it is justified by faster decisions or shorter lead times. The business case for organizational change brings both sides together in one calculation.

Niehues Consulting as a partner for the reorganisation

Niehues Consulting helps executive teams and divisional heads set up organizations so that they deliver reliably. Founder Marin Niehues is a management consultant with a delivery perspective who builds organizations that deliver. His projects range from VC-funded scale-ups to DAX 40 groups, and he has worked in 20+ countries on six continents.

In delivery management and organization design, Niehues Consulting steers programs as delivery manager, project manager or product owner and shapes structures and decision paths. The approach follows the Niehues Delivery Model with the phases Understand, Build and Roll out. Two checkpoint questions matter for the estimate. In the Understand phase: what is the baseline, and how do we measure success? In the Build phase: is the business case confirmed with real values? The cost model thus grows out of the actual workflow, and the decision on a new set-up rests on measured figures. The entry point is a free initial consultation of 30 minutes.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a reorganisation cost?

A reorganisation costs the sum of the four cost layers, from project costs to contingency. With 200 employees affected, transition costs alone quickly reach a high six-figure sum, as the worked example shows. A lump sum without this derivation remains an estimate without a basis.

Which reorganisation costs are most often overlooked?

The costs of the transition period are missing most often: the loss of productivity and the time managers spend on the change. They appear on no invoice and still affect deadlines and lead times.

How large should the contingency for a reorganisation be?

The contingency should be ten to 25 percent of layers 1 to 3. The lower end applies with experience from earlier programs, the upper end to a first reorganisation of this size or one spanning several sites.

How much is severance pay in a restructuring?

In Germany, the planning anchor is half a month's earnings per year of service under Section 1a KSchG. Social plans and termination agreements often apply a higher factor, so the budget works with two scenarios.

Is a social plan mandatory in a reorganisation?

For an operational change in a company with more than 20 employees entitled to vote, a social plan can be enforced through the conciliation board. For pure headcount reduction, additional thresholds apply under Section 112a BetrVG. The individual case is assessed by employment law specialists.

How are restructuring provisions accounted for?

Restructuring costs are recognized as a provision to the extent that an obligation to third parties exists, for example from severance pay or a social plan. Under IFRS, IAS 37 additionally requires a detailed formal plan and a valid expectation raised in those affected. Training and relocations are expensed as incurred.

How long does the productivity loss after a restructuring last?

The productivity loss lasts as long as onboarding into the new roles, three months in the worked example. Clear decision rights and key roles filled early shorten this period, and measuring on-time delivery and lead time shows when baseline performance is reached again.

Let’s talk about your initiative.

In 30 minutes we clarify where your organization stands and which step will pay off most now.

Request a consultation

30 minutes · free · no obligation