Transformation & Change

Co-Determination in Reorganisations: What Decision-Makers Should Consider Early

Marin Niehues9 September 202411 min read

Marin Niehues standing in front of a yellow presentation slide and addressing the audience in an event room.

In a reorganisation you involve the works council before the solution is fixed and treat the consultation as a milestone in the project plan. If the measure is an operational change, the German Works Constitution Act requires an attempt at a reconciliation of interests, and the works council can enforce a social plan. Co-determination therefore has a direct effect on timeline and cost. This article provides an overview and does not constitute legal advice.

What rights does the works council have in a reorganisation?

In a reorganisation the works council has rights to information and consultation, and in the case of an operational change a right to negotiate a reconciliation of interests and an enforceable right to a social plan. In addition, it has consent rights for individual personnel measures such as transfers. Which of these rights apply is determined by the type of measure and the size of the company.

The central provision is section 111 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). It applies in companies that normally employ more than 20 employees entitled to vote and covers operational changes that may entail substantial disadvantages for the workforce or significant parts of it. The Act lists examples, including the closure or relocation of establishments and their merger or division. Particularly relevant for reorganisations are a fundamental change to the organization of the establishment and the introduction of fundamentally new working methods. Whether a specific reorganisation reaches this threshold is something employment counsel clarifies before the first meeting.

The business decision rests with the executive team. It may only implement an operational change, however, after it has seriously attempted a reconciliation of interests. This sequence is the core of any timeline.

Yes, in companies that normally employ more than 20 employees entitled to vote, every transfer within the meaning of section 99 BetrVG requires the consent of the works council. The same applies to hiring and regrading. A reorganisation that assigns employees to new units or teams therefore often triggers a larger number of such individual procedures.

If the works council refuses consent, the company can apply to the labor court to have it replaced. For project control this means that assigning people to the new structure is a workstream of its own with its own lead time. Bundle the transfers and submit them with complete information. Agree the sequence with the works council. This prevents the new structure from formally applying while individual appointments are still open.

What happens if the works council is not involved?

A company that implements an operational change without attempting a reconciliation of interests owes the affected employees compensation for disadvantages under section 113 BetrVG, usually in the form of severance payments. The same consequence applies if the company departs from an agreed reconciliation of interests without compelling reason. Breaching information duties also risks an administrative fine of up to 10,000 euros under section 121 BetrVG.

The loss of time and trust weighs more heavily than the direct cost. A reorganisation that is decided without lead time and then presented goes into renegotiation. The solution is reopened and the timeline slips. Managers receive contradictory signals during this period. The works council can have transfers made without consent set aside by the court. Whoever examines the starting position jointly before the structure is fixed, by contrast, receives pointers to interfaces and skills that the project team lacks.

A five-phase process model

The following model arranges participation and the business decision in a sequence that protects both the timeline and trust.

  • Phase 1, clarify the initiative: The executive team sets objective and scope and appoints a project lead. Legal counsel checks whether an operational change is involved.
  • Phase 2, inform early: Starting position and problem are presented before a solution is chosen. The works council has the opportunity to contribute its assessment. Where an economic committee exists, it is informed in good time.
  • Phase 3, consult on options: Two structural variants are presented with their advantages and disadvantages. The consultation assesses them against the criteria from phase 1.
  • Phase 4, negotiate and agree: Reconciliation of interests and social plan are negotiated where an operational change is involved. The executive team decides, and the agreements are documented.
  • Phase 5, implement and adjust: Transfers run as bundled procedures, and implementation proceeds in waves with regular exchange on metrics.

Phases 2 and 3 determine the time gained. This is where pointers flow in while the structure can still be shaped, and where the trust is built that shortens the negotiation in phase 4. Phase 1 supplies the criteria: whoever defines in advance how a good structure is to be measured conducts the consultation along factual questions.

How long does the process with the works council take?

For the reconciliation of interests and social plan, plan two to four months; if negotiations fail, the conciliation committee extends the procedure by further months. For reorganisations below the threshold of an operational change, the process reduces to consultation and the transfer procedures, which can be concluded within a few weeks.

Plan the consultation as a milestone on the critical path, with a buffer before the decision. Backward scheduling starts from the desired implementation date. If a new structure is to apply from the start of a quarter, the agreement phase lies before it, the consultation on options before that, and early information before that. Each of these stages receives a buffer, because questions from the works council can trigger additional submissions.

Also define which work waits for the outcome of the consultation and which runs in parallel. Preparatory work that does not anticipate any decision continues, such as process analysis or planning of technical adjustments. Decisions on individual positions and appointments follow the consultation. This separation keeps the project moving.

A useful metric is the time between a question from the works council and its answer. If it lengthens, there is a control problem that can be fixed before the decision. A list of open questions, updated after every meeting and accessible to both sides, shows early which points endanger the timeline.

Communication and collaboration in the project

Works council and managers receive the same information as the workforce, in an agreed sequence. The works council learns news from the project before the employee communication goes out. A fixed slot in the project rhythm and one contact person on each side keep the exchange reliable.

Managers need a head start in knowledge and a conversation guide, because they answer the first questions in their teams. The wording is developed together with the project lead and HR.

How Niehues Consulting delivers reorganisations

Niehues Consulting treats co-determination as a fixed part of the project plan and delivers reorganisations using the Niehues Delivery Model in three phases. In Understand, the diagnosis of today's organization is produced, on which the documents for early information are based. The guiding question is: who decides, who delivers, who uses? In Build, structures and decision paths are designed and assessed as options, guided by the question of which interfaces operation needs. In Introduce, the transfer into everyday work and the enablement of managers follow. Here the question that counts is: are users enabled and processes adapted?

Marin Niehues steers such initiatives as Delivery Manager or Project Manager. He knows the delivery perspective from projects for VC-funded scale-ups through to DAX 40 groups, with assignments in 20+ countries on six continents. Employment law questions remain with the company's specialist lawyers. The entry point is a free initial consultation of 30 minutes, in which the timeline and participation roadmap of your reorganisation are clarified.

Frequently asked questions

When should the works council be involved in a reorganisation?

As soon as starting position and objective are settled and before a solution is chosen. In the case of an operational change the law requires timely information and consultation before implementation in any case. At this point, pointers can still be taken into the design.

What counts as an operational change under German works council law?

An operational change is a measure that may cause substantial disadvantages for the workforce or significant parts of it. For reorganisations, a fundamental change to the organization of the establishment is the most relevant case. The rule applies in companies that normally employ more than 20 employees entitled to vote.

What is the difference between a reconciliation of interests and a social plan?

The reconciliation of interests governs how and when an operational change is carried out, the social plan the compensation for economic disadvantages to employees. The company must seriously attempt the reconciliation of interests, but the works council cannot enforce it. The social plan can in most cases be enforced by the works council via the conciliation committee.

Which documents does the works council need?

As a rule, a target picture with rationale, organization charts before and after the change and details of the positions affected. A timeline with milestones and the planned training are added. For transfers the works council needs details of the person and the new area of work.

How long does the process with the works council take?

For the reconciliation of interests and social plan, plan two to four months. If negotiations fail, the conciliation committee extends the procedure by further months. Without an operational change, consultation and transfer procedures take a few weeks.

Does the works council have to approve a transfer?

Yes, in companies that normally employ more than 20 employees entitled to vote, consent under section 99 BetrVG is required. If the works council refuses, the company can apply to the labor court to have consent replaced. In reorganisations it pays to submit transfers in bundles.

What happens if the works council is not consulted?

A company that implements an operational change without attempting a reconciliation of interests owes the affected employees compensation, usually as severance pay. Breaches of information duties can lead to a fine. Delays follow as well, because the solution goes into renegotiation.

What is a conciliation committee?

The conciliation committee is a body of an equal number of members from each side and an impartial chair. It decides with binding effect where the law provides for it, for example on the social plan. Its involvement lengthens the procedure and causes additional cost.

Who decides on the reorganisation?

The business decision rests with the executive team. It may only implement an operational change after it has seriously attempted a reconciliation of interests; otherwise claims for compensation for disadvantages arise.

Let’s talk about your initiative.

In 30 minutes we clarify where your organization stands and which step will pay off most now.

Request a consultation

30 minutes · free · no obligation