The Leadership Team as a Team: How Top Management Works Together

A leadership team works as a team when it is jointly accountable for shared goals, has distributed decision rights clearly and takes decisions that no single member could take alone. The members of a management board or divisional leadership usually deliver their own area reliably. Whether they decide as reliably as a group shows in whether someone shapes the collaboration itself. This article describes four building blocks that turn a round of functional heads into a team that delivers together.
What is a top management team?
A top management team is the group of a company's most senior executives who are jointly responsible for strategy and overall results, usually the management board together with the heads of function reporting directly to it. Management research has studied this group since the 1980s. With their upper echelons theory, Donald Hambrick and Phyllis Mason showed in 1984 that the composition and collaboration of top management shape a company's results.
Formally, a top management team is therefore quickly defined. Whether it works as a team is a second question. Many leadership groups operate as reporting rounds: they meet regularly, report progress and take hardly any joint decisions. Research on top management teams has described this pattern for decades as the normal case that good teams overcome.
Functional heads or a team: where the difference shows
The difference shows in the agenda and in the decisions of recent months. The typical signs of a reporting round are easy to name. The agenda consists of status reports, and decisions are made in one-to-one conversations on the sidelines of the meeting. The same topics recur for months. Conflicting goals between functions remain unresolved until one individual settles them from above.
A simple test makes the position visible. Which decision did the leadership team take in the past quarter that no member could have taken alone? If none comes to mind, the group works as a sum of portfolios. From a delivery perspective, this is the decisive finding, because cross-functional initiatives only move forward when someone decides them across functions. The article characteristics and metrics of a high-performing organization describes how the leadership level fits into overall organization design.
Size plays a part. A leadership team of five to eight members can hold genuine trade-off discussions in a meeting. From around ten members, discussion turns into presentation, and decisions migrate to smaller circles. Organizations that need to involve more functions therefore separate the deciding core team from an extended group for information and alignment.
How does a leadership group become a team?
A leadership group becomes a team when it shapes four building blocks: a shared agenda, clear decision rights, a fixed rhythm and an agreed practice for conflict. Each building block answers a question that remains open in many groups.
The building blocks match the conditions that Ruth Wageman and Richard Hackman described with colleagues in their study of senior leadership teams. As essentials they name a real team with clear membership, a compelling shared direction and the right members. To these are added a solid structure, a supportive context and competent team coaching.
The first building block is the shared agenda. Each member is accountable for the goals of their own function. A team additionally needs a small number of goals for which all members stand together, such as the lead time of a cross-functional process or the introduction of a new technology. The number should be small enough for every member to name from memory, in practice three to five. When goals conflict, the shared agenda then takes precedence over functional goals. The leadership team decides this priority explicitly once, after which it eases every individual decision.
Half a day with all members is enough to develop the agenda. Each member brings the two topics that make their function most dependent on others. The team groups these topics and selects the few whose resolution moves more than one function forward. For each chosen goal it names a lead person and a date for the first review. The agenda thus becomes a work assignment.
Decision rights and rhythm
The second building block defines who has the final say on which type of decision. Frameworks such as RACI or RAPID help here, but their value only emerges when the leadership team applies them to its own recurring decisions. These include budget shifts between functions and the prioritization of joint initiatives. One page is enough, with decision type, deciding person, people to be consulted and deadline. The article Clarifying decision rights describes the details.
The third building block is rhythm, and separating formats by purpose has proven effective. Each week, a meeting of around 60 minutes resolves operational dependencies. Each month, half a day is devoted to steering the shared goals, working with a few metrics. Twice a year, the team works away from daily business in an offsite on strategy and collaboration. Each format has a fixed purpose and preparation. It ends with minutes recording decisions and owners.
Conflict practice and measuring impact
The fourth building block concerns how conflicting goals are handled. In a leadership team they are normal, because every function pursues its own goals. What does damage is avoiding them: conflicts shift into one-to-one conversations and return as delays. The team therefore agrees a fixed route. The conflict is named in the meeting, positions are recorded in one sentence per function, and the decision follows the agreed decision right.
Delivery shows whether the collaboration works. Three metrics are suitable as a starting point:
- Lead time of cross-functional decisions from proposal to resolution
- Share of decisions implemented by the agreed date
- Number of topics that appeared on the agenda several times without a decision
These values come from the minutes of the new rhythm and show after one quarter whether collaboration is changing.
What is the CEO's role in the leadership team?
The CEO or chair of the management board is accountable for the collaboration of the leadership team and shapes it actively. This includes defining membership, insisting on the shared agenda and ensuring that decisions are taken in the team instead of in one-to-one conversations.
In the meeting itself, the CEO switches between two roles. For decisions within the agreed rights, the CEO holds back and lets the team decide. For conflicting goals the team cannot resolve, the CEO decides and explains the decision. Facilitation of offsites and conflict resolution is handled by a person without a stake in the topics, such as an external consultant. This lets the CEO contribute on substance in these formats without also steering the process.
How do you develop a leadership team?
You develop a leadership team through joint work on real decisions, supported by an assessment at the start and a measurement after one quarter. Team training without reference to current decisions rarely changes behavior in the next meeting.
A shared agenda and a one-page summary of decision rights can be set within four to six weeks. The rhythm becomes established over two to three quarters. Only then does it become clear whether formats and metrics are actually used in daily work.
Niehues Consulting as a partner for leadership team development
Niehues Consulting supports management boards and divisional leadership in bringing these building blocks into operation. This is the delivery management and organization design service: shaping structures, the roles and the decision paths so that the organization delivers reliably. The approach follows the Niehues Delivery Model with the phases Understand, Build and Implement.
In the Understand phase, an assessment of existing committees and their rhythms is produced, including how decisions are actually made today. In the Build phase, roles and decision rights follow, together with the formats in which the team works. In the Implement phase, Niehues Consulting supports the first meetings until the team steers the processes itself. Three of the model's assessment questions matter most for a leadership team. Who decides, who delivers, who uses? What is the baseline, and how do we measure success? Which metric shows after 90 days that the solution is taking hold?
From a delivery perspective, what counts in the end is whether the leadership team achieves its shared goals. Founder Marin Niehues builds organizations that deliver, in projects from VC-funded scale-ups to DAX 40 groups. The entry point is a free initial consultation of 30 minutes.
Frequently asked questions
What distinguishes a leadership team from a group of functional heads?
A leadership team takes joint decisions across functional boundaries and is accountable for shared goals. A group of functional heads reports progress to one another and decides only for its own areas. The difference shows in the agenda and in the decisions of recent months.
How often should a leadership team meet?
A leadership team should meet weekly for around 60 minutes on operations, monthly for half a day on steering and twice a year for an offsite. The weekly meeting resolves dependencies, while the monthly format steers the shared goals. The offsites serve strategy and collaboration.
What is the ideal size of an executive team?
An executive team should have five to eight members so that genuine trade-off discussions remain possible in the meeting. From around ten members, decisions migrate to smaller circles. Larger organizations therefore separate a deciding core team from an extended group.
How can collaboration in a leadership team be measured?
Collaboration is best measured through delivery. Meaningful indicators are the lead time of cross-functional decisions and the implementation rate of decisions, plus the number of recurring topics without a decision. The values come from the minutes and can be compared quarter by quarter.
How long does it take for a leadership team to work as a team?
It usually takes two to three quarters for a leadership team to work as a team. A shared agenda and one page of decision rights can be set within four to six weeks. The rhythm takes longer to settle, because only daily practice shows whether formats and metrics are used.
Who should facilitate collaboration in the leadership team?
The chair of the management board is accountable for collaboration. Facilitation of offsites and conflict resolution is handled by a person without a stake in the topics, such as an external consultant. This person watches the rhythm and ensures that conflicts are voiced.
What belongs on the agenda of an executive team meeting?
The agenda of an executive team meeting should cover the metrics of the shared goals, open decisions with a proposal and deadline, unresolved conflicting goals and the review of earlier decisions. Status reports from the functions are circulated in writing beforehand. This keeps meeting time free for decisions.
Let’s talk about your initiative.
In 30 minutes we clarify where your organization stands and which step will pay off most now.
Request a consultation30 minutes · free · no obligation



