Organizational Design

Shared services and centers of excellence: when pooling makes sense

Marin Niehues22 May 202512 min read

Team placing sticky notes on a plan

Shared services pay off when a service arises in similar form across several units, a center of excellence when expertise is scarce and widely needed. Both models move responsibility from the units into a common entity, and that is exactly where their benefit and their risk lie. This article classifies the models, distinguishes them from global business services and outsourcing, and shows how to calculate the savings yourself. The perspective is delivery: a structure counts only when the service reaches the company's customers faster and more reliably. This article provides an overview and does not constitute legal advice.

What is a shared service center, in simple terms?

A shared service center is an internal unit that handles similar activities centrally for several divisions or legal entities of a company. Typical examples are accounts payable, travel expense processing, payroll, IT support and operational purchasing. The unit works like an internal service provider. It offers a defined service catalog, commits to service levels and lowers process costs through standardization and volume. The divisions hand over execution and keep responsibility for the results of their business.

A center of excellence pursues a different goal. It brings together specialists in one subject, such as data analysis, process design or AI, and provides the units with methods and standards. It also advises the units. The application stays in the units. The center ensures that quality and speed arise there that a single unit could not reach alone.

In practice, hybrid forms emerge. A center begins as a center of excellence and later takes over recurring tasks as a service. A group of experts grows out of a shared service center and develops the standards further. The distinction remains useful because it directs attention to what the entity is meant to deliver. How pooling fits into the wider picture of organization design is covered in the article characteristics and metrics of a high-performing organization.

Distinguishing shared services, global business services and outsourcing

The three terms differ on two points: who provides the service and how far the pooling reaches.

  • Shared services: a dedicated internal unit provides the service, usually for one function such as finance or HR. Steering runs through service levels and internal charging.
  • Global business services (GBS): the evolution of shared services. Several functions are run in one organization under joint leadership, often across several locations and time zones. GBS own end-to-end processes such as purchase to pay or order to cash and bring internal centers and external providers under one roof.
  • Outsourcing: an external provider delivers the service under a contract. The company keeps control but hands over staff and process knowledge, often the systems too. Changes run through the contract.

A simple rule applies to the choice between an internal unit and outsourcing. If the process is stable, well described and irrelevant to competitive position, the market is a serious comparison. If the process still has to be harmonized or contains knowledge you want to keep, pool internally first. Whoever outsources an undescribed process pays for every special rule as a contract variation.

Decision criteria for pooling

The decision for or against pooling can be structured with five criteria. Each yields a testable statement about the service concerned.

A service suits shared services when volume and repetition are high and specificity is low. It suits a center of excellence when knowledge is scarce and the application has to stay close to the customer. If volume and scarcity of knowledge are low, or the service is closely tied to the unit's customers, it stays in the unit.

How much does a shared service center save?

What a shared service center saves follows from your own process costs before and after pooling, less the one-off costs of the transition. Practitioner reports cite substantial savings on pooled process costs for well-established centers. Academic research is more cautious: a systematic review of administrative cost reduction through shared service centers finds that quantitative evidence based on objective financial metrics is largely missing, and that published figures mostly come from single case studies without a disclosed baseline. For executive management, this means an industry figure is no substitute for a business case. Calculate with your own values.

If payback exceeds three years, first check whether standardization within the units achieves the same effect without relocation. The biggest error in such calculations is a target taken from a benchmark instead of your own pilot.

Designing shared services: catalog, service levels, charging

A shared service center works when three elements fit together. The service catalog describes what the entity delivers and what it does not. The service levels fix quality and response time as measurable commitments. Governance regulates how units order services, how costs are allocated and who decides in a conflict.

There are two basic forms of internal charging. An allocation spreads total costs by a key such as revenue or headcount. It is simple but gives units no incentive to manage their demand. A price per service charges each transaction, for example per invoice or per ticket. It makes costs visible and forces the center to be efficient, but requires clean volume tracking. With more than a handful of services with clearly countable volumes, a price per service is the better choice. If the center serves subsidiaries abroad, tax transfer pricing applies on top, which must meet the arm's length principle and be documented.

The most common weak point lies in the handover. If an activity is relocated before it has been described, the entity inherits every special case of the unit and loses the economies of scale it was founded for. A relocation therefore follows this order: first describe and harmonize the process, then agree service levels, then transfer staff and systems.

Four metrics are enough for ongoing steering: lead time per request, error rate, cost per transaction and the satisfaction of the ordering units. The figures belong in a monthly session with the heads of the units, where it is decided which services enter the catalog or leave it.

Building a center of excellence: mandate, staffing, impact

A center of excellence gains impact through a clear mandate. It defines which standards are binding, which recommendations remain recommendations and which decisions continue to be taken in the units. Without a mandate, an advisory group emerges whose advice has no consequences. With too much mandate, a controlling body emerges that delays initiatives and is bypassed by the units.

Staffing follows the mission. Specialists with practical experience from the units gain more acceptance there than specialists with no contact with day-to-day business. A small core of experts has proved effective, supplemented by liaison people in the units who apply methods on site and feed experience back to the center.

The impact of a center shows in the metrics of the units. Suitable measures are the number of initiatives applying a standard and the time from idea to operation. Training figures document the center's activity, while shorter lead times in the units document its impact.

How long does it take to set up a shared service center?

For a first wave with one well-described process and a pilot unit, six to twelve months is a realistic planning frame, while pooling across several functions runs over two to three years. Duration is driven less by technology and location than by process maturity and consultation with employee representatives.

A staged approach has proved effective. First a pilot unit is selected in which the service is well described and the head of the unit supports pooling. There the catalog and service levels are tested and substantiated with figures. Only then do further units follow, and each stage draws on the experience of the one before.

Three risks determine success: relocating undescribed processes, distance from the customer for services with direct contact, and the employment law side. In companies with a works council, setting up a shared service center is generally a change to operations subject to co-determination, and carving it out into a separate legal entity constitutes a transfer of undertaking. Plan the consultation in from the first draft. What to consider early is described in the article on co-determination in reorganisations.

Two prerequisites decide the course. Executive management names a responsible person for the entity and equips that person with decision rights. The units receive a reliable commitment on what changes for them and a route for reporting problems during the transition. If either prerequisite is missing, units build parallel solutions and the pooling loses its purpose.

How Niehues Consulting brings pooling into delivery

Niehues Consulting supports pooling initiatives with organization design and delivery management. The basis is the Niehues Delivery Model with its phases understand, build and introduce. For shared services and centers of excellence, three of its review questions matter most. What is the baseline, and how do we measure success? Without a measured cost per transaction there is no robust business case. Which roles, decision paths and interfaces does operation require? This is where the service catalog and service levels arise, or the mandate for a center of excellence. Who owns operation from day one? The named head of the center takes over the entity with clear decision rights.

The introduction is run as a managed initiative, with a pilot unit and metrics through to a clear handover to the responsible line. The entry point is a free initial consultation of 30 minutes, in which your services are assessed against the criteria and possible pilot units are identified. You can arrange a conversation via the contact page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between shared services and a center of excellence?

Shared services provide recurring services for several units under defined service levels. A center of excellence pools expertise and provides methods and standards, while the application mostly stays in the units.

When do shared services pay off?

Shared services pay off when a service arises frequently and in comparable form across several units and can be brought to a common standard. The higher the volume and repetition, the greater the effect of standardization. If payback on the one-off costs exceeds three years, standardization within the units is the better first step.

What are global business services (GBS)?

Global business services are the evolution of shared services into a cross-functional organization. They pool services from finance, HR, procurement and IT under one leadership, own end-to-end processes and steer internal centers and external providers together.

What is the difference between shared services and outsourcing?

With shared services, an internal unit provides the service; with outsourcing, an external provider does so under contract. Shared services keep process knowledge and design freedom inside the company. Outsourcing suits stable, documented processes that are irrelevant to competitive position.

How are shared services charged internally?

Shared services are charged through an allocation key or a price per service. A price per service creates cost transparency and steers demand, while an allocation is simpler. For services to foreign subsidiaries, tax transfer pricing under the arm's length principle also applies.

What risks does pooling services carry?

The biggest operational risk is relocating undescribed processes, followed by distance from the customer and the employment law side. Setting up a center is generally a change to operations subject to co-determination, and a carve-out adds a transfer of undertaking. Documenting processes before relocation and using a pilot unit limit the first two risks.

How can you tell that a center of excellence is working?

A center of excellence is working when the units' metrics improve. These include the number of initiatives applying the standard and the time to operation. Activity figures of the center itself, such as the number of training sessions, say little about this.

Let’s talk about your initiative.

In 30 minutes we clarify where your organization stands and which step will pay off most now.

Request a consultation

30 minutes · free · no obligation