AI Adoption & Operations

Large Language Models Compared: What Decision-Makers Need to Know

Marin Niehues24 March 202510 min read

Statistics with line chart and page views

You compare large language models on six criteria that determine their value in operation and with a test on your own material, because public leaderboards go out of date with every model generation. For senior management and heads of function, a selection procedure is therefore worth more than a snapshot of the market. This article explains what a large language model is, positions the model families of the major providers and describes the criteria and test procedure through to regular operation. This article provides an overview and does not constitute legal advice.

What is a large language model?

A large language model (LLM) is a neural network trained on very large volumes of text that generates text by continuously predicting the most likely next piece of text. Put simply, the model has learned from billions of examples how language is structured and which content belongs together. On that basis it can answer questions, summarize or translate texts and write program code.

The technical foundation of almost all current models is the transformer architecture, which researchers presented in 2017 in the paper “Attention Is All You Need”. Two properties matter for decision-makers. First, a model knows only what was in its training data or what it is given at run time. Company knowledge must therefore be added through a connection to your own sources. Second, a model produces plausible answers even when they are wrong. Every application therefore needs a check of results that matches the risk of the task.

What large language models are there?

The market falls into two large groups: closed models that can be used only as the provider's service, and open-weight models that companies can also run themselves. The closed model families include GPT from OpenAI, Claude from Anthropic and Gemini from Google. Open weights are published by Meta with Llama, the French company Mistral AI as well as Alibaba with Qwen and the Chinese company DeepSeek.

Across this split, models differ in size and specialization. Large general-purpose models solve a broad range of tasks. Small models run on your own hardware or even on end devices and suffice for narrowly defined tasks such as classification or extraction. There are also models that work through several reasoning steps before answering. They are stronger at analysis and calculation tasks, but they respond more slowly and cost more. Multimodal models process images, documents or speech in addition to text.

What is the difference between ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Mistral?

ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Mistral differ mainly by provider, route of access and integration into existing software landscapes, rather than by a fixed ranking of quality. ChatGPT is OpenAI's application based on the GPT models, which can also be booked through Microsoft's cloud. Claude is Anthropic's model family, available directly and through the Amazon and Google clouds. Gemini is Google's model family, closely tied to Google Cloud and the company's office applications. Mistral AI is based in Paris and offers both open-weight and closed models, which is relevant for companies with requirements on processing location within the EU.

Which family leads on a specific task changes with every model generation. What counts for the decision is which route of access fits your existing cloud and data protection requirements, and how the model performs in your own test. How language models fit into overall AI management is described in the article AI management: what executive leadership must steer.

Why leaderboards offer little for the decision

Public leaderboards measure models on standardized tasks. These tasks rarely resemble a company's work, such as contract clauses in a particular industry or internal policies with their own terminology. Time is a further factor. Providers replace their models at short intervals, and the order at the top shifts accordingly. A decision based on today's ranking is out of date by the next budget round. Research draws the same conclusion: the HELM evaluation framework developed at Stanford University measures models in many scenarios and captures robustness alongside accuracy, because a single score does not capture fitness for a specific use.

For decision-makers this leads to a starting question that begins with the use case. Which task should the model take on? Who checks the result? What is a correct answer worth, and what does a wrong one cost? Only with these answers does a comparison of providers become meaningful.

Six criteria for the comparison

From a delivery perspective, six criteria are enough to assess a model both functionally and commercially.

Set the weighting before the first test so that the assessment does not follow enthusiasm for a demo. Score each candidate per criterion on a scale of one to five and multiply by the weight. The total gives a traceable ranking that senior management and the business unit can both stand behind.

Task fit: the test with your own material

The most important criterion can be measured only within your own company. The business unit compiles a set of representative tasks that contains simple cases as well as the difficult exceptions of daily work. Several models process the same set under identical conditions. Subject-matter experts assess the results against fixed criteria without knowing which model produced which answer.

The test set yields an error map. It shows for which task types a model works reliably and where a person must approve the result. The test set remains the company's property and serves as a regression test with every model change.

Data protection, operating model and integration

For data protection, the type of data comes first. Personal information and trade secrets require different conditions from public texts. The processing location and the contractual basis must be clarified, as must the question of whether inputs are used to develop the models further. The legal assessment belongs with your legal department or your data protection officer. An overview of the topics is given in Data protection and AI.

The operating model determines how much control the company gains and how much operational effort it takes on. Closed models are available only as the provider's service or through its cloud partners. Open-weight models can additionally be run on your own infrastructure, offer more control over data and customization and require specialist staff in return. Their licenses govern commercial use differently, from permissive licenses to the provider's own terms.

Integration determines acceptance in the business unit. A model that accesses company knowledge must respect existing permissions: employees see only content they are allowed to see in the source system. Raising this question only after the prototype costs months.

Costs and provider stability

The cost model takes two typical forms. Per-user billing is easy to plan and pays off as soon as license holders use the tool daily. With many occasional users, usage-based billing is cheaper. It follows the volume of text processed, measured in tokens, and fluctuates with use. A robust business case extrapolates consumption from the prototype data and accounts for integration and review effort alongside the model costs.

Provider stability is mainly about interchangeability. Providers change terms and models. An architecture with its own intermediate layer allows the model to be switched without rebuilding the application. Contractually, term and price adjustment must be checked, as must the handling of models being retired. When a model is replaced, the successor behaves differently with the same instructions, and the regression test shows whether the business unit still receives the expected result.

Niehues Consulting as a partner for model selection

Niehues Consulting accompanies the route from the task to the model in operation. In AI management, business analysis and the business case are produced along with the selection and sequencing of applications. The prototypes prove the benefit in the real workflow and supply the figures for the model decision. In operationalisation and rollout, Niehues Consulting moves the solution into operation with internal or external teams.

The approach follows the Niehues Delivery Model with the phases understand, build and implement. Three test questions matter for model selection. In the understand phase: which business outcome should change measurably? The weighting of the six criteria follows from this. In the build phase: does the prototype prove the benefit in the real workflow with real data? Here two or three candidates compete on the same test set. In the implement phase: who is responsible for operation from day one? This role maintains the test set and reviews the choice of model once a quarter. The entry point is the free initial consultation of 30 minutes.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best large language model for business?

The best language model for a business is the one that most reliably solves the business unit's tasks in a test on your own material and fits your existing cloud. The top of public leaderboards changes with every model generation. A selection procedure with your own test set and assessment by subject-matter experts, repeated at fixed intervals, is the reliable route.

What is an LLM in simple terms?

An LLM is a computer program that has learned from huge volumes of text how language works and then writes text itself. It predicts word by word what fits best next. That is why every answer sounds plausible, and why every application needs a check of the results.

What is the difference between open-weight and proprietary language models?

Proprietary models can be used only as the provider's service, while open-weight models can also be run in your own environment. Many open-weight models are themselves commercial products with their own license terms. For many companies a combination that uses different models depending on the task makes sense.

Is there a European large language model?

Yes, Mistral AI, based in Paris, is the best-known European provider of large language models and also publishes open-weight models. For processing within the EU, a US provider's model in a European cloud region is also sufficient, provided the contract guarantees this processing location.

How much does it cost to use a large language model?

Use costs either a fixed license per user and month or a price per volume of text processed, billed in tokens. The per-user license pays off with daily use, usage-based billing with many occasional users and with automated workflows. Integration and review come on top of the model costs.

How often should a company review its choice of model?

We recommend a fixed rhythm of once a quarter, supplemented by a review whenever a model in use is announced for retirement. The basis is the company's test set, which is run again at every review and extended with new cases.

Does a company have to commit to one provider?

A company does not have to commit to one provider. An intermediate layer between application and model keeps switching open and lowers the risk from price changes or retired models. A selection aid for procurement is provided in Choosing an AI vendor.

Let’s talk about your initiative.

In 30 minutes we clarify where your organization stands and which step will pay off most now.

Request a consultation

30 minutes · free · no obligation