AI Law, Risk & Governance

EU AI Act: What Companies Need to Know About the AI Regulation

Marin Niehues23 September 202411 min read

Leather-bound books on a shelf

The EU AI Act is the European regulation that sorts AI systems into risk classes and places specific obligations on companies according to their role and use case. Formally it is Regulation (EU) 2024/1689. It applies directly in all member states and also reaches companies outside the EU as soon as their AI systems are offered in the European market or their output is used there. This article provides an overview and does not constitute legal advice.

For the executive board this creates a management task: which AI applications are running in the company, which class does each fall into, and who is accountable for the consequences? The article sets out the structure of the regulation and shows how it translates into a controllable approach.

The structure of the regulation: risk determines the obligations

The regulation follows a risk-based approach. The greater the potential harm to health and safety or to fundamental rights, the stricter the requirements. For decision-makers the principle has a practical advantage, because it orders the work. Before a company considers individual obligations, it needs to know which AI systems it uses and which tier each belongs to.

The top tier consists of practices the regulation classes as unacceptable and prohibits, such as certain forms of social scoring. Below them sit high-risk systems. These include AI applications in sensitive fields such as recruitment or education, in critical infrastructure, and as a safety component of regulated products. They are subject to requirements on risk management and data quality, on documentation and human oversight, and on robustness.

Certain systems are subject to transparency obligations. With chatbots, it must be clear that a person is interacting with AI. Synthetically generated content must be marked in a machine-readable way, and deepfakes must be disclosed. Most of today's applications, such as spam filters, fall into the minimal-risk tier, for which the regulation sets no specific obligations. A separate regime covers general-purpose AI models and is aimed primarily at their providers.

Interactive tool

AI Act risk check

Answer a few questions about your AI system. The check assigns it to a risk class under the AI Act and lists the key obligations. It provides an overview and does not constitute legal advice.

This tool needs JavaScript to make a selection.

When does the EU AI Act apply?

The EU AI Act applies in stages: its obligations become applicable in a fixed order according to risk and addressee. The regulation was published in the Official Journal of the EU in 2024, and its individual parts apply step by step.

The binding dates are set out in the regulation itself. They can only be moved by an amending act of the European legislator, so planning must always rest on the version in force in the Official Journal. For the executive board this yields a clear rule: the inventory and AI literacy come first, because they apply first and every later obligation builds on them.

Who is a provider, who is a deployer?

A provider develops an AI system, or has one developed, and places it on the market under its own name, while a deployer uses such a system under its own authority in the course of business. Most mid-sized companies and large groups are deployers, because they use systems from software vendors or model providers.

The role can change. A company that markets a high-risk system under its own name, substantially modifies it, or repurposes a system so that it becomes high-risk is treated as a provider under the regulation and takes on the provider's obligations. The company settles this question before introduction, so that it does not surface during live operation.

For deployers of high-risk systems the obligations lie mainly in organizing the use. The system is used as intended, qualified people exercise human oversight, operation is monitored and logged, and employees are informed about the use. In addition there is the AI literacy duty under Article 4, which applies to all deployers and providers regardless of risk class.

These obligations are organizational tasks at their core. Oversight and monitoring only work if someone takes them on with the necessary authority and the process is anchored in day-to-day operations. This is where the legal text turns into delivery.

What are the penalties for breaching the AI Act?

Breaches of the AI Act can lead to fines of up to 35 million euros or 7 percent of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher. This ceiling applies to prohibited practices. The regulation grades penalties by the severity of the breach.

For small and medium-sized enterprises, including start-ups, the lower of the two amounts applies in each case. Beyond the fine, the operational consequences matter to the executive board: an authority can require a system to be withdrawn from the market or its use to be stopped. How fines are calculated in individual cases is a matter for specialist lawyers.

From regulation to delivery: a four-step approach

Companies that implement the regulation in a controlled way proceed in a fixed order.

  1. Inventory: it records every AI system in use, including systems developed by the company itself, embedded functions in purchased software and applications that business units have introduced on their own. Use is regularly broader than central IT knows.
  2. Classification: for each system, the intended purpose and the company's role are documented together with the risk class. Business units and IT work with legal expertise, because the intended purpose determines the classification and the business unit knows it best.
  3. Responsibilities: who approves a new system? Who exercises human oversight? Who reports incidents, and to whom? These questions belong in a governance model with named roles.
  4. Anchoring in operations: this includes approval processes for new applications, reporting with indicators, training for the roles concerned and a fixed rhythm in which the executive board reviews the AI portfolio.

Only with the fourth step does an inventory become a procedure that also works for new systems and changing personnel. The legal assessment of individual cases rests with qualified lawyers.

Where implementation stalls in practice

Three patterns recur. First, the inventory remains incomplete because it is set up as a one-off survey. Second, responsibility sits with a single function, such as the legal department or data protection, while decisions on use are taken in the business units. Third, policies sit on the intranet because nobody translates them into the workflow.

From a delivery perspective the remedy is the same in all three cases: each requirement is translated into a role and a process and given an indicator. An inventory has an owner and an update rhythm. An approval has a process with deadlines. A training course has a target group and a measure of success.

Niehues Consulting as a partner for implementation

The requirements of the regulation can be met reliably when AI management and organization design work together. Niehues Consulting in Düsseldorf combines both from the delivery perspective. Founder Marin Niehues builds organizations that deliver and brings AI into operation, in projects ranging from VC-funded scale-ups to DAX 40 groups across 20+ countries on six continents.

In AI management, the inventory of applications is built with business analysis and requirements, followed by the business case, a reasoned sequence and portfolio steering. In organization design, roles and decision paths are defined so that approval and oversight work in daily business. The approach follows the Niehues Delivery Model with its three phases. Three of its review questions matter most for implementing the regulation: Who decides, who delivers, who uses? Which roles and decision paths does operation require? Who owns operation from day one? A free 30-minute initial consultation is the starting point and can be arranged via the contact page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the EU AI Act?

The EU AI Act is Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 on artificial intelligence. It creates a uniform legal framework for the development, distribution and use of AI systems and divides them into classes according to risk. The higher the risk, the more extensive the requirements for documentation and oversight.

Who does the EU AI Act apply to?

The regulation applies to providers and deployers of AI systems that are placed on the market or used in the EU. This includes companies based outside the EU where the output of their systems is used in the EU. For most mid-sized companies and large groups the deployer role is the relevant one.

Which AI systems count as high risk?

High-risk systems are AI applications in fields of use that the regulation classes as particularly sensitive, such as recruitment and employee evaluation, credit assessment, education or critical infrastructure. AI used as a safety component of regulated products is also covered. What matters is the specific intended purpose of the system within the company.

When does the EU AI Act come into force?

The EU AI Act applies step by step, starting with the prohibitions and the AI literacy duty. The rules for general-purpose AI models follow, then the high-risk obligations. The binding dates are set out in the version of the regulation in force in the Official Journal of the EU.

Can the AI Act be delayed?

The application dates of the AI Act can only be moved by a formal amending act of the European Parliament and the Council. Planning should therefore rely solely on the version in force in the Official Journal. Inventory, classification and AI literacy pay off regardless of the date, because every later obligation builds on them.

What are the fines under the EU AI Act?

Prohibited practices can draw fines of up to 35 million euros or 7 percent of worldwide annual turnover, and breaches of the other obligations up to 15 million euros or 3 percent. For incorrect information supplied to authorities the ceiling is 7.5 million euros or 1 percent. For small and medium-sized enterprises the lower amount applies.

Does the AI Act apply to using ChatGPT at work?

Yes, a company that uses ChatGPT or a comparable assistant for work is a deployer of an AI system and must at least ensure the AI literacy of its staff. If it uses the assistant with customers, transparency obligations are added. If it is used for a high-risk purpose such as screening job applications, the high-risk obligations for deployers apply. The obligations for the underlying model lie with its provider.

Which authority supervises the AI Act?

Each member state designates its own market surveillance authorities. In Germany the legislator sets out responsibility in a separate implementing act, and the Federal Network Agency is regarded as the obvious choice for the central authority. Existing sector supervisors remain responsible for individual areas such as financial services. At European level, the Commission's AI Office supervises providers of general-purpose AI models.

Let’s talk about your initiative.

In 30 minutes we clarify where your organization stands and which step will pay off most now.

Request a consultation

30 minutes · free · no obligation