Organizational Design

Connecting Innovation Units to the Core Business

Marin Niehues2 March 202612 min read

Marin Niehues speaking with a microphone and clicker in front of a glass facade, wearing a speaker pass.

An innovation unit is a team that tests new products, services or business models outside the routines of the core business, whether it is called a lab, an incubator or a digital unit. It delivers impact when the executive team gives it a mandate and a fixed handover route leads its results into operation. This article describes the four connections that decide the outcome, compares the organizational models and shows how an organization can design the handover as a delivery process.

Why do innovation units remain isolated?

Innovation units remain isolated because their freedom comes from their distance to day-to-day business, and the same distance makes later adoption difficult. Their results have to be absorbed by structures that played no part in creating them.

The typical pattern is familiar. The unit presents a convincing prototype, the executive team shows interest, and then no division can be found to take over budget and operation. The prototype remains a demonstration. The cause lies in the organization around the unit: it lacks a mandate with clear decision rights, a route into the line organization and a counterpart there who wants the result.

Research on ambidexterity supports this finding. In the study by Charles O'Reilly and Michael Tushman, breakthrough innovation initiatives achieved their goals in more than 90 percent of cases when they were organized as a separate unit and linked to the core business at senior management level. Fully detached units performed markedly worse. The wider framework is set out in the article Ambidexterity: Optimizing the Core Business and Building the New.

Four connections that determine impact

From a delivery perspective, the connection can be divided into four areas. Each area answers a question that is settled before a unit starts.

The mandate defines what contribution to corporate strategy the unit makes. It names the fields in which the unit works and the decisions it may take on its own. Without this demarcation, the unit competes with business functions for topics, and every decision ends up with the executive team. How decision rights can be described cleanly is shown in the article Clarifying Decision Rights.

Budget steering determines how reliable the work can be. Staged funding, also known as metered funding, has proven effective: the unit receives funds for one phase, and at the end there is a decision based on criteria agreed in advance. This spreads the risk, and the executive team sees early on which initiatives continue. The link to ongoing budget planning is described in the article Portfolio Management: Linking Budgets to Value Streams.

The handover is the moment when a result moves from experiment to part of the business. It needs a recipient and an operating concept. The budget for operation sits with the recipient's division. The section further below covers it in detail.

Finally, the exchange of people connects both sides in daily work. Specialists from the core business work temporarily on the unit's initiatives, and members of the unit accompany the rollout in the division. As a result, the recipient knows the result before taking it over, and the unit understands the conditions of operation before it builds.

Three organizational models compared

In practice, three basic forms can be distinguished. In the integrated unit, the team belongs to a division and works on its topics. The independent unit reports directly to the executive team and works with its own budget. The network model makes do with a small core team and brings in specialists from the divisions for the duration of individual initiatives.

The choice follows the remit. The integrated unit suits topics that a single division can implement. The independent unit suits initiatives that go beyond today's business. The network model is the right fit when many divisions are affected and the core team is to stay small. In every model, the four connections are designed explicitly. How the unit fits into overall organization design is set out in the article characteristics and metrics of a high-performing organization.

Incubator, accelerator and venture builder: what is the difference?

An incubator supports ideas and early teams over a longer period until they are ready to be founded as companies; an accelerator speeds up existing start-ups in a fixed-term program; and a venture builder builds new companies itself. For corporates, the form determines who takes the risk and where the result ends up.

The same rule applies to the connection as for internal units. An accelerator without a named recipient in a business function produces pilot projects that end when the program ends. A venture builder needs a decision from the outset on whether a result will later be brought back into the core business or managed as an independent holding.

When is a spin-off better than a handover to the core business?

A spin-off is the better choice when the new business requires a different profit model from the core, conflicts with the core's customers or sales partners, or needs external capital and equity for key people. In these cases, a handover to the core business holds the initiative back, because the core's metrics and approvals are geared to the existing model.

A handover to the core business is the better choice when the result improves existing products, processes or customer relationships. It then uses the core's sales and operations, and building separately would duplicate effort. In between lies a separate business unit within the company, which has its own metrics and uses the core's resources according to fixed rules.

Budget, size and duration: the planning parameters

For the budget, the widely used 70/20/10 rule serves as a guideline: around 70 percent of innovation funds for improvements in the core business, 20 percent for adjacent areas and 10 percent for fundamentally new activities. The executive team sets the ratio annually and releases funds per initiative in stages.

For size, the rule is that an innovation unit stays small enough to manage without its own administration. In practice, a team per initiative that fits around one table works well, that is five to nine people, supplemented by specialists from the divisions on a temporary basis. The reasons are described in the article on team size. If the unit grows beyond several such teams, it needs a portfolio with clear decision dates.

For duration, three markers apply. First validated learning results, such as confirmed customer problems, are available after three to six months. A result ready for handover, with proven value in the real workflow, takes six to 18 months. A new business area with meaningful revenue of its own takes several years. Steering therefore measures the unit on learning results and handovers in its first year, and on revenue only after that.

The handover as a delivery process

A handover succeeds when it is planned like an initiative with its own deadlines and owners. This begins before the first prototype. Unit and recipient agree on the conditions under which the recipient will take over a result. This agreement removes the element of surprise from the handover.

In the transfer phase, unit and recipient work in a joint team. The unit contributes knowledge of the solution and how it was created; the recipient contributes knowledge of workflows and systems. At the end of the phase there is an operation that the division runs itself, and the unit withdraws to devote itself to the next initiative. A delivery manager or product owner keeps to the schedule and resolves dependencies. Decisions that stall between the two sides are escalated.

How Niehues Consulting connects innovation units

Niehues Consulting works at the interface between the unit and the core business. In delivery management and organization design, the work produces structures and decision paths that make a handover possible: a mandate with clear decision rights, staged funding and a handover process with a named recipient. Marin Niehues steers the initiatives himself as delivery manager, project manager or product owner and therefore knows the bottlenecks that arise at such transitions.

The approach follows the Niehues Delivery Model with its phases Understand, Build and Introduce. Three test questions matter most for innovation units. Who decides, who delivers, who uses? Does the prototype prove its value in the real workflow with real data? Who is accountable for operation from day one? The first question names the recipient before the start, the second guards against demonstrations without impact, and the third secures the handover. Where the unit develops AI prototypes, the transfer into operation is added, including enablement of the business functions. The entry point is a free 30-minute initial consultation in which the unit's situation and its connection to the core business are assessed: book an appointment.

Frequently asked questions

What is an innovation unit?

An innovation unit is a team that tests new things outside the routines of the core business, such as new products or business models. It works with its own mandate and frequently with its own budget. Its results have value as soon as they run in operation, whether in the core business or in a new business unit.

Why do corporate innovation labs fail?

Innovation labs fail when they lack a mandate with decision rights, a route into the line organization and a recipient. Convincing prototypes then remain without operation, regardless of the quality of the ideas.

Where should an innovation unit sit in the organization?

Its placement follows its remit. Topics affecting one division belong in an integrated unit. Initiatives with an impact across several divisions need a link to the executive team, and the mandate and decision rights are set down in writing.

What is the difference between an incubator, an accelerator and a venture builder?

An incubator supports early ideas over a longer period until they are ready to be founded. An accelerator supports existing start-ups in a fixed-term program, usually lasting three to six months. A venture builder develops business ideas with its own team and spins them out as new companies.

What is metered funding for innovation initiatives?

Metered funding, or staged funding, releases money per phase rather than for the whole initiative. At the end of each phase, the executive team decides on continuation or termination against criteria agreed in advance. This limits risk and shows early which initiatives are promising.

How much budget should a company plan for innovation?

The 70/20/10 rule serves as a guideline for allocation: 70 percent for improvements in the core, 20 percent for adjacent areas, 10 percent for fundamentally new activities. The executive team sets the total budget annually, and funds are released per initiative in stages.

How large should an innovation unit be?

A team of five to nine people per initiative works well, supplemented by specialists from the divisions on a temporary basis. The unit stays small enough to manage without its own administration.

How long does it take for an innovation unit to deliver results?

First validated learning results are available after three to six months, and a result ready for handover after six to 18 months. A new business area with revenue of its own takes several years.

When is a spin-off better than a handover to the core business?

A spin-off is better when the new business requires a different profit model, conflicts with the core's customers or needs external capital. If the result improves existing products or processes, a handover to the core business is the better choice.

Let’s talk about your initiative.

In 30 minutes we clarify where your organization stands and which step will pay off most now.

Request a consultation

30 minutes · free · no obligation