# Self-organization: what holacracy and similar models deliver

Author: Marin Niehues, Niehues Consulting · Published: 2026-07-27 · Updated: 2026-11-16 · Organizational Design
Source: https://www.niehuesconsulting.com/blog/self-organisation-holacracy-models/

Holacracy and similar models move decisions from line managers into roles and teams, and they speed up delivery where local decisions set the pace. The prerequisites are a well-practiced rulebook and clear decision rights. Where both are missing, the result is coordination effort without pace, and several well-known companies have returned to hierarchy for this reason. This article describes the mechanics of holacracy, compares it with sociocracy and other models, and names five conditions under which self-organization delivers.

Self-organization is therefore a question of design that can be tested against criteria. How it fits into the design of structures and decision paths as a whole is described in the article [characteristics and metrics of a high-performing organization](/blog/high-performing-organisation/).

**Self-organization delivers faster when decision rights and goals are defined in advance and a procedure for conflicts is in place. Without these, it shifts coordination into conversations.**

## What self-organization changes in delivery

In a classic line organization, a decision is taken where the hierarchy places it. A team waiting for approval delivers only when the next level has time. Self-organization starts at this point: it defines which decisions a team or a role takes itself, and thereby removes waiting time from the process. The effect shows in lead time. Decisions that used to pass through several levels are taken where the knowledge of the problem lies.

The gain comes with a condition. If a team may decide, it must also know where the company is heading and where its authority ends. Self-organization thus replaces leadership by line managers with a rulebook. Whoever designs this rulebook redesigns the organization, even if no organization chart changes.

## What is holacracy and how does it work?

Holacracy is the most formalised model of self-organization: it replaces jobs with roles, groups roles into circles and governs all decisions through a written constitution. Brian Robertson developed it from 2007 onwards with the company HolacracyOne. Each circle has a purpose and decides for itself within its boundaries, and circles are nested within one another.

Two types of meeting keep the model running. In the governance meeting, the rules of collaboration are changed, meaning roles and responsibilities. In the tactical meeting, ongoing work is coordinated. The trigger for any change is a tension, meaning a perceived gap between the current state and what the role could achieve. A rule change is adopted through a fixed objection procedure. It takes effect as soon as there is no objection that meets the test criteria of the constitution, that is, one that demonstrably names harm to the circle.

**The mechanics of holacracy**
- Roles instead of jobs: tasks and accountabilities are tied to roles, and people fill several roles.
- Circles: roles with a shared purpose form a circle, and circles are nested within one another.
- Governance meeting: roles and rules of collaboration are changed here.
- Tactical meeting: ongoing work is coordinated here.
- Objection procedure: a proposal takes effect as soon as no objection meets the test criteria of the constitution.

### Are there bosses in holacracy?

Holacracy has no managers with authority over people, but it does have roles with clearly limited authority. The most important is the lead of a circle, long called the lead link in the constitution and now the circle lead. It assigns people to the roles in its circle and sets priorities. How a role does its work is decided by the person filling that role. The constitution does not govern personnel matters such as pay and hiring; the company sets these separately.

## What are the advantages and disadvantages of holacracy?

The greatest advantage of holacracy is clarity about responsibilities, the greatest disadvantage the high effort needed to introduce and maintain the rulebook. Both sides can be named concretely.

**Advantages and disadvantages of holacracy**
Criterion | Advantage | Disadvantage | With Niehues Consulting
Responsibilities | Every task has a named role | Many roles per person make the overview harder | Roles only where they remove waiting time
Speed of decisions | Local decisions without approval | Cross-unit questions need procedures of their own | Decision rights fixed for each type of decision
Adaptability | Roles change continuously through governance meetings | Frequent changes cost meeting time | Changes on a fixed rhythm with measured effect
Introduction | Uniform, documented rulebook | Learning effort for all staff, break with familiar leadership | Step by step with pilot teams and key figures

Research on self-managing organizations confirms both sides. A widely cited review from Harvard Business School defines such companies as organizations that decentralize authority formally and systematically throughout the organization and remove the reporting relationship between managers and subordinates. Review articles in organizational research describe how formal self-organization clarifies roles and decisions, and they stress at the same time that robust comparisons of its effect on performance are rare. For executives this means measuring the effect in their own pilot instead of deriving it from case stories.

## Examples: which companies use holacracy?

The best-known example is the US online retailer Zappos, which introduced holacracy across the company from 2013. The case became controversial in 2015: management offered a severance package to all staff who did not want to follow the new path, and a noticeable share of the workforce accepted. Critics saw this as evidence that the rulebook overwhelmed people, while the company itself cited other reasons for most departures. In the following years Zappos developed the model into a form of its own.

The publishing platform Medium worked with holacracy for several years and returned to a structure with managers in 2016. The company gave as its reason that the coordination effort had persistently held back its effectiveness. Beyond these, holacracy or adapted variants are used mainly by smaller software firms, agencies and consultancies. In healthcare, the Dutch home-care organization Buurtzorg is a well-known example of self-managing teams, though without a holacratic constitution.

These cases yield a rule. Introducing holacracy across the whole company at once is the riskiest approach. A pilot in a unit with a high need for local decisions shows whether the rulebook brings more speed there than it costs.

## Self-organization compared with other models

Holacracy is one of several answers to the same question. The main alternatives differ in their degree of formalisation:

- **Sociocracy:** the Dutch engineer and entrepreneur Gerard Endenburg developed it in his company in the 1970s. It also decides by consent, meaning without a paramount objection, and connects circles through double linking, in which one person represents the circle upwards and another downwards. Unlike holacracy, it mainly governs how decisions are made and leaves the structure of roles more open. Newer versions such as Sociocracy 3.0 offer individual patterns to choose from.
- **Teal according to Laloux:** in "Reinventing Organizations" (2014), Frederic Laloux described companies that work without classic hierarchy and assigned them to a stage of development he called Teal. Teal is a description of characteristics such as self-management and wholeness, not a rulebook.
- **Autonomous product teams:** companies give teams responsibility for a product and keep the line for people and resources. The Spotify model with squads and tribes, described in 2012, follows this pattern, although Spotify itself stresses that it was a snapshot and not a blueprint. Scaled models are compared in [scaled agile frameworks compared](/blog/scaled-agile-frameworks-comparison/).

What counts for the choice is what the organization has to deliver. The more stable and repeatable the output, the less self-organization is needed. The more the business depends on fast, local decisions, the more it pays off. A comparison with other methods for clarifying responsibilities is offered in [clarifying decision rights: RACI, RAPID and their limits](/blog/decision-rights-raci-rapid/).

## Five conditions under which self-organization delivers

From the delivery perspective, five conditions apply, to holacracy as much as to any lighter form. The list serves as a checklist before any introduction.

1. **Clear decision rights:** every team knows what it decides alone, what it coordinates and what lies with others.
2. **A binding goal:** teams need a direction derived from strategy and measurable against key figures.
3. **Expertise in the team:** whoever may decide needs the knowledge for the decision. Without it, the team remains dependent on others.
4. **A procedure for conflicts and priorities:** where two teams pursue conflicting goals, it is settled who decides.
5. **Practiced leadership:** managers move from making decisions to shaping the conditions for them. This role has to be learned.

An organization that meets all five conditions can introduce self-organization broadly. If three or fewer are met, it starts where the conditions already exist and builds the others step by step. The operating model that sets out these conditions is covered in [operating model](/blog/operating-model-before-structure/).

## How the transition succeeds

The most common mistake in the introduction concerns sequence. The rulebook is introduced before decision rights are clear, and teams have procedures but no authority. A robust transition begins with analysis: which decisions slow down delivery today, and who takes them? On this basis, a pilot is set up with one or two teams whose results can be measured by lead time and on-time delivery.

[Niehues Consulting](/) supports this transition as a partner for delivery management and organization design. Marin Niehues is a management consultant from the delivery perspective who builds organizations that deliver, in projects from VC-funded scale-ups to DAX 40 corporations and on assignments in 20+ countries on six continents. The approach follows the Niehues Delivery Model with the phases Understand, Build and Implement. Two test questions matter most for self-organization. In Understand: who decides, who delivers, who uses? The answer shows which decisions are waiting today and where they belong. In Build: which roles, decision paths and interfaces does operation need? This question prevents a rulebook that regulates more than necessary. Broad roll-out follows only once the pilot has shown in its key figures that it delivers faster. How teams are put together across unit boundaries is shown in [introducing cross-functional teams](/blog/cross-functional-teams-prerequisites-and-pitfalls/).

**Use self-organization deliberately**
Self-organization pays off where speed arises from local decisions. It needs defined decision rights, a binding goal and practiced leadership. Those who start with a pilot and measure the effect on lead time and on-time delivery decide on the breadth of roll-out based on data. An [initial conversation of 30 minutes](/#kontakt) clarifies which parts of your company are suited to it.

**Sources**
- Robertson, Brian J.: Holacracy. The New Management System for a Rapidly Changing World, book, 2015
- Lee, Michael Y.; Edmondson, Amy C.: Self-managing organizations. Exploring the limits of less-hierarchical organizing, Research in Organizational Behavior, journal article, 2017
- Endenburg, Gerard: Sociocracy. The Organization of Decision-Making, book, 1998
- Laloux, Frederic: Reinventing Organizations, book, 2014

## Frequently asked questions

### What is holacracy?

Holacracy is an organizational model that replaces jobs with roles, groups roles into circles and moves decisions into the circles according to a written constitution. Brian Robertson developed it from 2007 onwards with HolacracyOne. Rule changes take effect as soon as no objection meets the test criteria of the constitution.

### What is the difference between sociocracy and holacracy?

Sociocracy is the older model and mainly governs decision-making by consent and the double linking of circles. Holacracy takes up the idea of consent and adds a comprehensive constitution for roles, circles and meetings. Sociocracy therefore leaves companies more room in how they shape it.

### Why is holacracy at Zappos controversial?

Zappos introduced holacracy across the company from 2013 and in 2015 offered a severance package to all staff who did not want to follow the new path. A noticeable share of the workforce left. Critics saw this as the rulebook overwhelming people, while the company cited mostly other reasons.

### Which companies is self-organization suitable for?

Self-organization suits units in which fast, local decisions are decisive and teams have the necessary expertise. For stable, highly standardized processes, a lighter model with clear decision rights is sufficient.

### What distinguishes holacracy from agile teams?

Agile teams organize work within a team. Holacracy additionally governs the structure of the whole company, meaning roles and circles as well as the procedures by which both change.

### What does Teal mean according to Laloux?

For Frederic Laloux, Teal denotes a stage of development of organizations built on self-management, wholeness and an evolving purpose. Laloux described it in 2014 in "Reinventing Organizations" using case examples. Teal is a guiding image without a fixed rulebook.

### How do you measure whether self-organization works?

Meaningful measures are lead time and on-time delivery, plus the number of decisions taken without escalation. Comparing them with the state before the pilot shows whether shifting decisions has had an effect.
