# Change management models compared: Kotter, Lewin, ADKAR and what matters in execution

Author: Marin Niehues, Niehues Consulting · Published: 2026-07-09 · Updated: 2026-11-16 · Transformation & Change
Source: https://www.niehuesconsulting.com/blog/change-management-models-compared/

Kotter steers large programs through eight steps, Lewin explains the force field around a change, and ADKAR takes the individual from awareness to habit. The right model depends on the level at which your initiative is stalling.

This article sets the common models side by side, places the change curve in context and sets out the criteria for choosing between them.

## Why there are several change models

Change management models describe the same change from different angles, which is why they complement each other more often than they compete. Some look at the organization as a whole and ask in which order leadership must act. Others look at the individual employee and ask what has to happen in that person before they work differently.

Since a widely cited review by Karl Weick and Robert Quinn in 1999, organizational research has distinguished two basic forms. Episodic change is a bounded transformation with a beginning and an end, such as a reorganisation or the introduction of a new ERP system. Continuous change is the ongoing adjustment of day-to-day business. The classic models of Lewin and Kotter were written for episodic change. Organizations that change permanently also need leadership routines that no phase model replaces.

**A change model is a framework for leadership decisions. It only becomes effective once every step is assigned an accountable role, a date and a measure.**

How change initiatives fit into the design of the organization is covered in the article [characteristics and metrics of a high-performing organization](/blog/high-performing-organisation/).

## Lewin: unfreeze, change, refreeze

The model attributed to Kurt Lewin describes change as the transition between two stable states in three steps. Unfreezing calls the current state into question, changing produces the new behavior, and refreezing anchors it in new rules and routines.

The more valuable part of Lewin's work is force field analysis. Every state of an organization is an equilibrium between driving and restraining forces. The practical rule follows directly: reducing restraining forces achieves more than increasing driving forces, because additional pressure usually creates counter-pressure. If you want to introduce new software, removing duplicate data entry gains you more than another email from the executive team.

One research finding matters for context. Stephen Cummings and two co-authors showed in 2016 that Lewin himself never left a fully developed three-step model. The familiar version took shape after his death in 1947, built from a few paragraphs of his last paper. That does not reduce the value of the image for communication, but it explains why the model is too coarse for detailed planning.

## Kotter: eight steps for large programs

John Kotter published his eight steps in 1995 in an article on why transformation efforts fail, and developed them in his 1996 book "Leading Change". By his own account, the basis was his observation of more than 100 companies. The steps are:

- Establish a sense of urgency
- Form a guiding coalition
- Create a vision and strategy
- Communicate the vision
- Remove obstacles and empower people
- Generate visible short-term wins
- Consolidate gains and produce more change
- Anchor the new approaches in the culture

The model's strength is the sequence of leadership tasks. It names the two errors that most often set large programs back: declaring victory too soon, and a guiding coalition that lacks weight or cohesion. For programs spanning several divisions and running for more than twelve months, Kotter is therefore the right framework for the steering committee.

Its limits are equally clear. A literature review by Steven Appelbaum and colleagues in 2012 found research support for most of the individual steps, but no study that tested the model as a whole. The model also says little about what a single team does differently in the week after the announcement. Models at the level of the individual close this gap.

**The 70 percent failure figure**
Presentations on change management regularly claim that 70 percent of all change initiatives fail. In 2011 Mark Hughes examined five frequently cited sources of this figure: none of them rests on a sound empirical basis. Justify change effort with the risks and baseline values of your own initiative instead.

## ADKAR: five building blocks for the individual

ADKAR describes five conditions that a person must meet in sequence before they work differently for good. Jeffrey Hiatt published the model in book form in 2006. The letters stand for:

- Awareness of why the change is needed
- Desire to support and shape the change
- Knowledge of how the new way of working functions
- Ability to apply it in daily work
- Reinforcement that sustains the new behavior

ADKAR's practical value lies in diagnosis. When an implementation stalls, you can determine for each group which building block is holding it up. A department that understands the reason but gets no time to practice is stuck at Ability. Training will do little for it, while freed-up capacity helps immediately. A department that has been trained but sees no benefit for itself is stuck at Desire. What helps here is an answer to the question of what improves in its own work.

ADKAR's limit is its perspective. The model explains one person's path and says nothing about structure and decision rights, or about sequencing within a program.

## What phases do employees go through during change?

According to the change curve, employees facing significant change pass through seven phases: shock, denial, rational insight, emotional acceptance, experimentation, discovery and integration. The curve goes back to the stages of grief that Elisabeth Kübler-Ross described in 1969, and Richard K. Streich adapted it to organizational change in the German-speaking world.

The shape is familiar: perceived competence and performance drop after the announcement, reach their low point between rational insight and emotional acceptance, and then rise above the starting level. For leadership, the low point is the decisive moment. This is where people either try the new approach or return to the old one.

**Exhibit 1 (Schematic): After the announcement perceived competence falls, with the low point between rational insight and emotional acceptance**

| Series | Before the announcement | Shock | Denial | Rational insight | Emotional acceptance | Experimentation | Discovery | Integration |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Perceived competence and performance | 6 | 4 | 3 | 1.5 | 1.5 | 3 | 5 | 7 |

Schematic illustration, not measured data.
Note: schematic of the change curve after Streich, values without a unit
Graphic: [SVG](https://www.niehuesconsulting.com/blog/change-management-models-compared/grafik-1.svg) · [CSV](https://www.niehuesconsulting.com/blog/change-management-models-compared/grafik-1.csv) · [JSON](https://www.niehuesconsulting.com/blog/change-management-models-compared/grafik-1.json) · Niehues Consulting, [CC BY 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en)

A related model comes from William Bridges, who in 1991 distinguished the external change from the internal transition. His transition has three stages: the ending of the old, a neutral zone of uncertainty and the new beginning. Leaders who do not name what is ending with the change prolong the neutral zone.

Both curves are thinking tools, not measured laws. Grief research has explicitly rejected the Kübler-Ross stage model for supporting bereaved people, because people skip or repeat stages. Use the curve as a basis for conversations with managers and to plan when support is needed. It is unsuitable as a timetable for individuals.

A review by Shaul Oreg and colleagues in 2011 summarizes what research shows about reactions to change. It analyzed 79 quantitative studies published between 1948 and 2007. Factors that shape how people respond include trust in leadership and participation in the process, as well as the quality of information. How to read resistance early is explained in the article [Resistance to change](/blog/resistance-to-change/).

## Which change model fits which initiative?

The right change model follows from the scope and level of the initiative: Kotter for cross-divisional programs, ADKAR for new ways of working in clearly defined groups, Lewin's force field analysis for situations that have stalled. For large initiatives, combine two levels.

**Change models by purpose**
Criterion | Kotter and Lewin | ADKAR and change curve | With Niehues Consulting
Level | Organization and leadership team | Individual and group | Organization and team in one delivery plan
Strength | Sequence of leadership tasks, force field made visible | Precise diagnosis of which block a group is stuck at | Every step linked to a role and a measure
Limit | Little guidance on the daily work of individual teams | No guidance on structure and decision rights | Requires access to real usage and delivery data
Suitable when | Several divisions, duration over twelve months | New tools or processes for defined user groups | The change has to arrive measurably in operations

Three criteria determine the choice. If the initiative affects more than two divisions or more than one management level, you need an organization-level framework such as Kotter. If daily work changes for a defined group, for example through a new system, you need person-level diagnosis such as ADKAR. If an initiative has stalled despite clear decisions, start with a force field analysis and look for the restraining forces.

## What matters in execution

In execution, success depends on translating the model into roles and measures. As early as 1990, Michael Beer and colleagues described how company-wide programs built on training and mission statements change little as long as daily work in the units stays the same. Change happens where responsibilities and processes are redefined.

Every phase of a model therefore needs a counterpart in operations. Kotter's "urgency" becomes a measured baseline. ADKAR's "ability" becomes protected time for practice in the real process. Lewin's "refreezing" becomes revised process descriptions and objectives. How to convey the change through channels and managers is described in the article [Communication in transformation](/blog/communication-in-transformation/).

**Checklist before launching a change initiative**
- The baseline of the measure that is meant to change has been recorded.
- For each affected group it is defined what they will do differently after the change.
- Each phase of the chosen model has an accountable role with a date.
- Managers of the affected teams have scheduled time for support.
- The plan gives users time to practice in the real process.
- A review after 90 days checks whether the new behavior has taken hold in daily work.

AI implementations add a particular feature. The new way of working keeps changing with every improvement to the tool, so Lewin's refreezing becomes an ongoing task. How change management leads AI applications into daily use is shown in the article [Change management for AI implementations](/blog/change-management-ai-adoption/).

## Niehues Consulting as a partner for change initiatives

A partner for change management should be able to choose a model and also take responsibility for its steps in delivery. [Niehues Consulting](/), based in Düsseldorf, combines organizational design with delivery management. Marin Niehues builds organizations that deliver and, where needed, takes on the role of delivery manager or product owner himself. His projects range from VC-funded scale-ups to DAX 40 corporations, with assignments in 20+ countries on six continents.

The approach follows the Niehues Delivery Model with its phases Understand, Build and Implement. Three of its review questions matter most for change initiatives. In Understand: who decides, who delivers, who uses? In Implement: are users enabled and processes adapted? And: which metric shows after 90 days that the solution is landing? These questions connect ADKAR's individual level with Kotter's program level and make progress measurable. The free 30-minute initial consultation clarifies at which level your initiative is stalling, and you can [book it via the contact page](/#kontakt).

**Key takeaways for decision-makers**
Choose the model by the level of the problem: Kotter for programs across several divisions, ADKAR for new ways of working in defined groups, Lewin's force field analysis for stalled situations. Use the change curve as a basis for conversations with managers. Translate every phase into a role with a measure and check after 90 days whether the new behavior has taken hold in daily work.

**Sources**
- Appelbaum, Habashy, Malo, Shafiq: Back to the future: revisiting Kotter's 1996 change model, Journal of Management Development, 2012
- Cummings, Bridgman, Brown: Unfreezing change as three steps: Rethinking Kurt Lewin's legacy for change management, Human Relations, 2016
- Hughes: Do 70 percent of all organizational change initiatives really fail?, Journal of Change Management, 2011
- Kotter: Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail, Harvard Business Review, 1995
- Oreg, Vakola, Armenakis: Change Recipients' Reactions to Organizational Change: A 60-Year Review of Quantitative Studies, Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 2011
- Bundesverband Deutscher Unternehmensberatungen (BDU): Honorare in der Unternehmensberatung, fee study 2022

## Frequently asked questions

### What are the main change management models?

The most widely used change management models are Kotter's eight-step model, Lewin's three-step model with force field analysis, ADKAR and the Bridges transition model. Kotter and Lewin work at the level of the organization, ADKAR and Bridges at the level of the individual. Large initiatives typically combine one model from each level.

### What is the difference between Kotter and ADKAR?

Kotter describes what leadership must do and in which order, while ADKAR describes what must happen within an individual. Kotter is therefore suited to steering a program across several divisions. ADKAR is suited to diagnosing why a particular group is not yet applying a new way of working.

### What does unfreeze, change, refreeze mean?

Unfreeze, change, refreeze are the three steps of the model attributed to Kurt Lewin: loosen the current state, implement the change and stabilize the new state. The image works well for communication. It is too coarse for planning, which is why it is usually combined with a more detailed model.

### How long does the change curve last?

The change curve has no fixed duration, because people move through the phases at different speeds and sometimes in a different order. Plan support for the period between rational insight and emotional acceptance, where performance hits its low point. Measure progress by actual use of the new way of working, for example in a review after 90 days.

### Is Kotter's 8-step model still relevant?

Kotter's eight-step model remains a useful framework for large, time-bound programs. A 2012 literature review found support for most of the individual steps and no evidence against the model. For continuous change, add leadership routines such as fixed cycles for feedback and adjustment.

### How much does change management consulting cost?

In the German market, external consulting is typically billed at around 1,000 to 2,500 euros per consultant day, according to the fee study of the German consultancy association BDU. Total effort depends on the number of divisions affected and the duration of support. A proposal becomes reliable when it ties services to the phases and measures of the initiative.
